But Amber, why the morbid fascination?

Russ wrote this comment:

First: “There’s something deeply disturbing about their obsession…”

Now: “Yes, another one in the series. What can I say, I must be some kind of masochist. This’ll be my next book review.”

Hmmmm……

I answered:

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Eat my contradictory ass.

And then:

Actually I’m going to write a post that’s a lengthier and at least mostly-serious answer to Russ’s thinly veiled attempt to “get” me.

So here is the lengthier reply I promised.

First, let’s get one thing straight. I make no bones about it: I am obsessed with sex.1 Aside from actually doing it, I like thinking about it, reading about it, and talking about it, in an academic sense and otherwise. I enjoy thinking about the place of sex in society, where sexuality fits in the context of identity as a whole, how prevailing societal attitudes about sex leave their mark in other, seemingly unrelated areas, and so on and so forth. In short, I am a sex nerd.

As such, I have given considerable thought to all these issues, and I have clear opinions about them. I think there’s a lot that’s fucked-up, for lack of a more highbrow word. I fervently wish for people/society to get over their/its fucked-up attitudes about sex.

I obviously have my opinions about how things should change for the better. So when I read, hear, or see something that is pretty much the polar opposite of my well-thought-out, thoroughly researched, and over-analyzed ideas of How To Make the World a Better Place, I want to understand what the hell could make people think that way. When I read things like, “A wife’s body isn’t her own, and she’s the only legitimate vessel of sexual satisfaction for her husband on earth” or “we lead mediocre lives where women take control of their own bodies and husbands are ‘forced’ to masturbate,” it makes me punch myself in the face and yell, “What the fuck?!2 Not content simply to say, “Fuck these people, they’re seriously screwed up and I don’t have time for them,” I am morbidly fascinated with what can cause so many people to have such warped views of sexuality.

They say that if you want to successfully defeat your enemy, you must understand them. You might think the word “enemy” is too strong here; but when we’re talking about people who want to pass laws to severely restrict what I can and can’t do with my own body, or who want to use my tax dollars to fund “faith-based” initiatives and feed my children abstinence-only education bullshit filled with sexist propoganda such as “[w]omen gauge their happiness and judge their success by their relationships; men’s happiness and success hinge on their accomplishments” and downright wrong biological information such as “[t]wenty-four chromosomes from the mother and 24 from the father join to create [a fetus]” - well, then I consider them my enemies.3

I want to understand where, why, and how they get their ideas. I want to get inside their heads - well, as much as possible, before it just becomes creepy. If I can do that, at some level I actually harbor the delusion that I can talk some sense into them.

Yeah, I know, I should probably get over that.

1 I don’t mean obsessed the way Garrett defined it, and which is probably the more correct definition. But cut me some slack, my thesaurus was not being helpful.

2 Both quotes from Every Man’s Marriage.

3 Quotes from the abstinence-only education textbook Why kNOw.

4 Responses to "But Amber, why the morbid fascination?"

  1. Balthazar B says:

    Your intellectual vigor makes me, another sex geek, quite proud.

  2. Alyssa says:

    I definitely understand where you are coming from and I applaud you the patience to be able to get through that stuff without screaming and tearing the book into tiny pieces.

    I try to do the same thing with politics - i try to listen to Bill O’Reilly and Sean Hannity to see what the other side’s talking points are and what topics they think are important, but I usually only last about 10 minutes and have to change the channel when my fists are bruised from beating the steering wheel.

  3. Russ says:

    In further defense of you, I pretty much knew all of what you wrote in this post.

    I do the same thing with pseudoscience, pseudotherapies, and more general codswallop and intellectual treachery. I also knew that my “Hmmmm…” would do at least something to goad you a little, so it was fun that it actually did. Sometimes it’s fun to pretend I’m a psychoanalyst and to see others as projecting.

    Goad is a truly strange word.

  4. Rusty says:

    Heh, that might not have been a mistake when they were talking about 24 chromosomes. You might recall from freshman year biology that 24 chromosomes = kid who rides the short bus. It’s not such a stretch to think that the people who would subject themselves and/or their kids to this drivel are a few bricks short of a house.