I have a brief intermission from training; why use it for anything but blogging? Admittedly, this is merely a rehashing of a comment I posted on Tony’s site, but whatever, you know you need your Being Amber Rhea fix. </hubris>
You’ve heard of the proposed HPV vaccine, yes? If so, you’ve probably also heard that certain Christian wingnuts are opposed to it*. Their reasoning? Get ready for some truly bass-ackwards bullshit. They claim that if people get vaccinated for HPV, they will see it as a license to fuck, fuck, and fuck some more.
Now, I don’t know about you, but when I got my tetanus vaccine, I didn’t see it as a license to go dance on a bed of rusty nails.
An HPV vaccine would be particularly useful because approximately 80% of the population is exposed to HPV at some point in their lives, and most people who have it go their entire lives never knowing they have it, because they don’t have symptoms. Without symptoms, HPV is almost impossible to test for. (Gah! I ended a sentence with a preposition!) So people spread it to others without even knowing they have anything to spread in the first place. Furthermore, it is possible to contract HPV without overtly sexual contact, since it’s spread by skin-to-skin contact. But the religious wackos wouldn’t be interested in hearing about the less juicy aspects of communicable infections.
Here’s one of my favorite explanations about the religious right’s position on the HPV vaccine, from the Family Research Council. This was written as part of a “defense” against allegations that their group espouses wholesale opposition to the vaccine.
While we welcome medical advances such as an HPV vaccine, it remains clear that practicing abstinence until marriage and fidelity within marriage is the single best way of preventing the full range of sexually transmitted diseases, unwanted pregnancies, and negative psychological and emotional consequences that can result from sexual activity outside marriage.
Okay, that’s great, sweetie. (Aside: someone named Amber wrote that press release. Nice.) But let’s step out of your insanely simplistic worldview for a second, okay? You can be as pure as the driven snow until your wedding night, and end up contracting HPV from your husband, who never knew he had it. Even if he was a Virgin Soldier until he married you, maybe he and a high school girlfriend let their hormones get the better of them ten years ago and engaged in some “heavy petting,” and bam, he got HPV. I won’t even go into all the other everyday scenarios, like people getting remarried after a divorce, or asinine debates such as whether those who cheat on their spouse don’t deserve the same standard of medical care, because it’s just boring to repeat all that stuff after a certain point.
(I should also mention that this vaccine would only prevent the strains of HPV that can lead to cervical cancer. There are hundreds of strains of HPV, most of which cause no symptoms. Some strains, known as “low-risk” HPV, can cause genital warts in a small percentage of infected people; this vaccine would prevent only “high-risk” strains. This concludes your excessively long parenthetical statement.)
Let’s face it: these religious right folks are anti-sex, and that’s all there is to it. There’s something deeply disturbing about their obsession with sex and their reactionary desire to rid the world of it altogether. It doesn’t matter that all the things they claim will lead to more unwanted pregnancies, more STIs, more (gasp!) pre-marital sex - e.g., comprehensive sex education; access to contraception; safe and legal abortions; etc. - have been shown, over and over again, to decrease all these things, whereas abstinence-only education and a lack of access to contraception increases them. But then, common sense and a basic understanding of causation and correlation is lost on such folks, so what can you do.
* This article, like many written by someone with a religious agenda, is at best grossly oversimplified and at worst downright misleading in its description of HPV. That should come as no surprise, since FUD is a favorite tactic of these groups; but it never fails to piss me off, because it only serves to perpetuate the cycle of ignorance in the general population.